Thinking of Bennigan's

Butters' mom is curious as to what she'll get his year for her anniversary and enlists Butters to sp...

The Stotches meet other, more famous, people who knew victims of "some Puerto Rican guy."

Butters braves the cursed road to South Park to get back in time for his parents' anniversary.

Butters' Parents decide to come clean and tell everyone what horrible, lying, perverted, crazy, murd...

Mr. Stotch teaches Butters the value of little white lies, but soon finds it's too late.

Butters makes a visit to the White Swallow, where he catches his father in a compromising position.

The Stotches address the media and plead with "some Puerto Rican guy" to bring their son back.

Mrs. Stotch saves Butters from being raised by a sick pervert by sending him in the lake, locked in ...

Inspector Butters comes home with a full report for his mom on her husband's whereabouts, which incl...

Butters' dad finds his wife ready to hang herself. He talks her out of it only to find she has sent ...

As Butters' mom paints to get everything clean, she realizes the only way to clean Butters is to kil...

Butters returns home and teaches his parents the importance of telling the truth.

Officer Barbrady gets Butters off the phone to keep the line clear for his abductors. The Ramseys sh...

Butters makes his way through a creepy forest with only the Bennigan's theme song to keep him compan...